Scott McIntyre, a favorite of my friend Adrian, was voted out of American Idol Season 8. Though he did try to do something different by singing along with his guitar, it did not work out for him. He hit the bottom three along with Anoop Desai (who did well but just doesn’t seem to have enough fans) and Lil Rounds (who was clearly disappointing). But in the end it was Scott McIntyre who got evicted.

The judges were divided about giving Scott another shot at glory, but he couldn’t bag the chance. Simon Cowell decided that it was the end of the road for him. Adrian groaned in disappointment. I wouldn’t say Scott McIntyre was bad, but I really have doubts if he was American Idol material. I mean, if he wasn’t evicted this week, it wouldn’t have been long before that happened. Do you agree with me? Do you think think he had a definite chance to be American Idol? I’d like to know if we think alike on this.